>> This is just your assumption, who is asking any one to credit GNU for
>> a non GNU project? The system is indeed GNU system with Linux as a
>> kernel. When the kernel was completed, the only thing you need is to
>> add is the GNU system to make it an OS. And the kernel was also
>> completed using GNU tools. Under such a situation, why do you think
>> we are asking for a thing that we didn't deserve?
> Hehehe. Thank you. Exactly what I needed to hear from an FSF
> representative. Now would you be so kind as to make sure everyone who
> tries to spread GNU philosophy is clear upon this point?
What do you mean? I think you never needed to hear anything from any
FSF representative. You need to tender an apology. Pray do not start
throwing mud around, and then do a 'hehehe'. Get me one GNU hacker who
said Linux is owned by GNU.
> I've had arguments with people about this, even during the RMS lecture. Pity,
> for the lack of time on RMS' part meant that I couldn't bring up this
> issue right there.
Does not mean you level false charges and go 'hehehe'.
> There goes Vihan's argument from the Andheri BoF. Granted that he did
> not mean that GNU owned the kernel, but I suppose he has no right to
> say this:
> "But Linus himself uses GCC to build the kernel.."
Eh? Why can not Vihan say so? Linus Torvalds said he could not have
made Linux without GCC. He does say GCC is used to compile Linux.
> Yes, well the point is, to a layman, who is completely new to this
> world, the word GNU doesn't make any sense.
Ok fine. So what makes sense? Linux? The X factor is it, eh?
For all the reasoning, Linus Torvalds can be labelled as egoistic, if
one went by the anti-FSF lobby. After all Linus named the kernel after
himself, while Stallman never named GCC as 'Stallman Compiler
Collection', Emacs as 'Stallman Editor', and the Free Software
Movement as 'Stallman's Movement', and GNU as 'Stallman is Not
Proprietary'. :-) But many GNU people do think Linux sounds cool, so
why throw mud at GNU?
Regards,
Debarshi
--
Microsoft does have a Y2K problem... it's called GNU/Linux!